Contact Information

By Phone

Corporate Offices: 1-800-333-3735
Claim Service: 1-800-333-3371
Customer Service: 1-800-333-3735

By Mail

Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company
Attn: Corporate Communications
6400 Brotherhood Way
Fort Wayne, IN 46825

Need Insurance?

For more than 90 years, Brotherhood Mutual has provided quality property and liability insurance coverage, custom designed to help churches and related ministries do their work safely and effectively. Find out more by visiting

Back to Top